|
Post by FIREHORSE on Jun 11, 2009 18:19:27 GMT -5
Jason also has not contributed anything to make me take the vote off him either. My suspect list in no particular order: Firehorse - Slyly excused Jason because he wants to keep him around a bit longer. Why exactly? A non contributor hurts the town. Soylentred - Did the same thing with Firehorse. Also says that Merlin and Noodle are not helping. ( I agree with the Noodle part, but his gameplay has not changed yet) If anything makes me suspicious it is the person who misquotes you and passes it off as fact. You notice he did not quote me to say this. To say I 'slyly excused' him yada yada yada is ridiculous. I said the exact opposite - I said Fire is a good person to keep around because if he is town he is going to say something very insightful and helpful to the town and we should watch for it. He is very logical. I did not say just keep him in even tho he is not contributing - even his seemingly throw away remarks should be paid attention to. I disagree with this post. I think everybody in this game is logical and I don't think Firehorse is that good of a player at all
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Jun 11, 2009 18:51:31 GMT -5
I disagree with this post. I think everybody in this game is logical and I don't think Firehorse is that good of a player at all [/quote] You might be right - maybe you should go back and retry your spelling on the word vote - I would hate to see something arbitrary effect the game.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Jun 11, 2009 18:55:06 GMT -5
I am going to vote this way - it seems to be the way we are rolling.
My other choice is Merlin if people want to switch off and go that way.
Vote:Nolecub
|
|
|
Post by colorlessgreen on Jun 11, 2009 20:21:56 GMT -5
I'd really like to think that nazdakka would allow that, as it's quite obviously a typo and his intent is apparent, but:
@firehose: You typed "voe" rather than "vote". Please correct?
-CG
|
|
|
Post by colorlessgreen on Jun 11, 2009 20:22:39 GMT -5
FIREHORSE. Yay for typoing in a post about typoing.
-CG
|
|
|
Post by goltar on Jun 11, 2009 21:03:19 GMT -5
I don't know the trick of how you guys do it of getting multiple quotes in one post - but there are so many bits of what people have said here that I would like to comment on. Bear with me. What I do is open the "quote" link in a new window for each post I want to quote from (or multiple for one if I want separate parts quoted separately) and copy/paste each into one reply window. If I've got a really monster post (for me) I tend to put it together in notepad so I've got a better chance to review it without accidentally posting only part. Sometimes those posts can take me an hour or two to write. Goltar - He gives me a fairly good vibe, but he's been quiet for a while now. He has made a few useful posts, and has asked some questions. He has also promised more insights and his suspicions later today, something I'd be interested to read. Not later today, just later. I'm still figuring things out. I do have a theory for today though. I believe cg is on to something with nolecub's vote switching. However, the flip side I see to that is cg could be jumping on it as an easy townie lynch. My call for the moment is to lynch nolecub today, and if he shows townie, seriously consider cg as tomorrow's lynch. Vote: nolecub
|
|
|
Post by goltar on Jun 11, 2009 21:09:05 GMT -5
Gah, I got names mixed up. Sub merlin in for nolecub in my last paragraph. I'm going to keep my vote on nolecub, as he's more likely to get lynched with the current vote count, and there's no point giving the mafia more room to play with the vote at the end of the day.
And the final point is that if nolecub does show mafia, we seriously consider merlin as tomorrow's lynch.
|
|
|
Post by FIREHORSE on Jun 11, 2009 21:22:27 GMT -5
I don't know the trick of how you guys do it of getting multiple quotes in one post - but there are so many bits of what people have said here that I would like to comment on. Bear with me. What I do is open the "quote" link in a new window for each post I want to quote from (or multiple for one if I want separate parts quoted separately) and copy/paste each into one reply window. If I've got a really monster post (for me) I tend to put it together in notepad so I've got a better chance to review it without accidentally posting only part. Sometimes those posts can take me an hour or two to write. Goltar - He gives me a fairly good vibe, but he's been quiet for a while now. He has made a few useful posts, and has asked some questions. He has also promised more insights and his suspicions later today, something I'd be interested to read. Not later today, just later. I'm still figuring things out. I do have a theory for today though. I believe cg is on to something with nolecub's vote switching. However, the flip side I see to that is cg could be jumping on it as an easy townie lynch. My call for the moment is to lynch nolecub today, and if he shows townie, seriously consider cg as tomorrow's lynch. Vote: nolecubI don't know Goltar, must disagree with you here - I think CG did some pretty good detective work on Noleclub regardless of whether he shows Town or Mafia. I would not target CG just because Noleclub shows town (Assuming he does). The goal of the town is to play detective and try to sniff out the bad guys. CG did that. I would not expect anything else from a Townie and his reason is valid. VOTE: NoleclubSorry for my earlier typo
|
|
|
Post by FIREHORSE on Jun 11, 2009 21:24:23 GMT -5
Change above post from CG to Merlin. I just compounded Goltar's error. I won't vote Merlin just because Noleclub may show Town. I need a better reason than that.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Jun 11, 2009 21:34:17 GMT -5
OMG you guys are making me laugh - it is like you are bumbling towards brilliance or something ;D
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Jun 11, 2009 21:42:26 GMT -5
It's like the 3 stooges all trying to get out the same door.
Thanks everyone for the multiple quoting instructions.
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Jun 11, 2009 23:01:04 GMT -5
bumbling towards brilliance my new sig (I won't change in the middle of a mafia game but it's mine as soon as it's over) *ahem* I've actully found merlin to be the more suspicious, therefore I have to ask why nole over merlin? and what makes merlin safe if nole is town? MERLIN changed his vote once CG put his vote on nole. It's been MERLIN who's been trying to follow along without appearing to and giving excuses. I've never had a problem with merlin and language before now, second (or 20th) language or not his posts have always been coherient before. They're lacking the keen edge I expect. Now I will grant that nole is still dangerous in the both-mafia, mutual-finger-pointing-at-each-other-to-throw-off-suspicion scenario. But I'm concerned at the band wagon begun after he's gone for the day. vote: merlin
|
|
|
Post by Jason Maher on Jun 12, 2009 0:27:10 GMT -5
Thank you whoever questioned my post questioning the discussion of the night 1 kill. The whole point of the post was to keep the talk going. Nothing generates discussion better than someone taking a contrary position. Now, nole: I didn't originaly find your vote for me suspicious at all. However, your reasoning for sticking with an admitted joke vote are rather flimsy. Most notable, you completely misquoted me. I said we need to get a bad guy lynch either today OR tomorrow unless the doctor is successful at preventing a NK. Simple mathmatics says if the doc misses, and we lynch two townies day 1 and 2, then with 3 townies NKed by day 3, it is 4 mafia vs 3 townies - game over. Thinkign a bit more and expanding on what I originally said, the vital lynch is tomorrow. It would be wonderful if we netted a scum today - would give us a fighting chance, but the reality is we have little to no information to go on, so it would basically be a fluke unless someone stuffs up. Now misrepresentation is a fairly flimsy excuse to vote on, but it the best I have, so: vote: nolecubNow, in my own defence, I'm not going to post reams purely to take suspicion off myself. If I have something to say, I will say it. If someone has already said what needs saying, then I will be inclined to not say much. Anyway, hopefully this post meets nole's and merlin's exacting standards.
|
|
|
Post by Jason Maher on Jun 12, 2009 0:28:26 GMT -5
p.s. I start work in an hour, so I'll miss the close of the poll. For better or worse, that is my final vote.
|
|
|
Post by Jason Maher on Jun 12, 2009 0:34:52 GMT -5
p.p.s. I have been playing mafia on another forum, and have a tendency to lay low at times (and post excessively at other times). The trick is, I have been a townie in all but the current game (which I can't reveal one way or the other because it is still going and I was NKed). To be honest, I tend to post more conscientiously when I'm a baddie or a power role (look at my past games here and on the SPF).
|
|