|
Post by goltar on Nov 6, 2009 11:46:10 GMT -5
Vote: nolecub
I don't believe you nolecub. Why? I'm the herbalist. And if there's any concern, I can (somewhat) easily prove it, though I don't like the method. The herbalist's vote does not count in a tie. So if there's a tie, my vote will not be counted. Right now, it won't matter, as w_m received the vote first. But if one of fbz and w_m votes for nolecub, and THEN the other votes for w_m, that will put nolecub in lynching position. My vote would be ignored, w_m would get lynched, my role is proven.
Why don't I like this? We can't afford to sacrifice someone just to prove my role. That puts us in a very bad situation of I have to guess who nole will target to prevent his NK.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on Nov 6, 2009 14:39:06 GMT -5
Would you care to explain why there was no NK then?
Why would you not say who you protected to try and refute me? Because you haven't gotten that far in your story yet.
I gave you the benefit of the doubt on Day 1 thinking you were the mystery role. FBZ has proven that he is indeed the mystery role. Why did you not protect him last night if you are the herbalist?
I am not buying what you are selling. Very convienent that the "only" way to prove your claim is one you do not want to use.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on Nov 6, 2009 14:43:03 GMT -5
Excuse the double post.
Unvote: w-m
Vote: goltar
|
|
friedbananazzzz
New Member
My eyes are blue, and I don't lie about there being silver in them.
Posts: 47
|
Post by friedbananazzzz on Nov 6, 2009 17:20:22 GMT -5
Wheee! It worked! And especially fortunate that I managed to save myself. Either Nole is telling the truth and saved me last night, or was unsuccesful and decided to claim herbalist to not get lynched... I'll give him the benefit of the doubt, goltar seems a little more shady to me. vote: goltar
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Nov 6, 2009 17:40:33 GMT -5
why claim the role second? He could have just tried for plain ol' townie. And he's got a point of bein' able to prove bein' a doc, had YOU left your vote the same. A plain old townie claim would have left it his word vs. another. Better yet WHY CLAIM AT ALL??? just vote fer lynchin' me or stay out of it and wait on fbz. He weren't under the gun none.
There weren't no point to makin' a FALSE claim. UNLESSS: 1. My silver bullet was 'cause the west is wild enough 'fore people start turning into critters, but HAD I been a healin' type, yer claim jumpin' would be settin' me up to look mighty bad. or 2. most folks agreed to the claiming thing and the fido wanna be figures he oughta come out guns blazin'. It's "Shoot FIRST ask questions later" not "toss yer 2 cents in then let the other guy take a pot shot before ya draw."
Now, here's the de-lema as to the whole tie thing, other than I don't much go in for doin' away with myself... if it's just you an him tomorrow mornin, don't matter how long you take to wander in and vote he looses. If it's you and fbz, it's a quick draw -- who ever gets in the vote first wins. Unless he can keep folks waitin' for the sherriff day after day, in which case you get 'em at night. (and I have to say whoever he is it's mighty nice of our wolfie to not go on a proper rampage killin' spree or just visit some one else ifn he don't like how one o' us is smellen')
Now goltar could be lyin' and hopen' some one points out the logical reasons like above, but I'd be the dead one if that were the case, he don't like leaven' me around too long when he's wicked and you said you protected fbz* *shrug* therefore he ain't running with the Pack (that and he hates football), sorry Mowgli, you lose.
Vote: nolecub
*he'd a claimed townie to challenge me today in the hopes of doin' me in if he hadn't targeted me last night in an effort to look like "someone else"
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Nov 6, 2009 17:48:04 GMT -5
hey, fbz, come back!
dang it! I too long trying to have my say.
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Nov 6, 2009 17:54:28 GMT -5
p.s. is this day ending in about 23 hours or 35?
|
|
|
Post by goltar on Nov 6, 2009 18:04:37 GMT -5
Would you care to explain why there was no NK then? Why would you not say who you protected to try and refute me? Because you haven't gotten that far in your story yet. I gave you the benefit of the doubt on Day 1 thinking you were the mystery role. FBZ has proven that he is indeed the mystery role. Why did you not protect him last night if you are the herbalist? I am not buying what you are selling. Very convienent that the "only" way to prove your claim is one you do not want to use. What is there to gain by stating who I protected? It was fbz (though I wasn't fully convinced to protect him immediately), but there is no way to prove that, as we have no idea who was targeted. For all we know, you simply didn't do anything last night in hopes of drawing me out. Not the best of options, but it is a valid strategy. It doesn't matter all that much at the moment, fbz believes you over me, and since my vote doesn't count in a tie, a tie means I get lynched. I will be proven truthful on my lynch, as if you were the herbalist, your vote wouldn't count, and even though you reached the tie second, you would be lynched. So as the vote stands right now, the herbalist will be lynched whichever of us it is. I'm not changing my vote, as I know it's right. I doubt you will, as my death secures your victory. So fbz and w_m, you two will decide the game now. Keep your votes as they are, and the town loses. If the correct change is made (fbz, you need to switch your vote), the town wins. If fbz or w_m is lynched, we have a 50/50 chance, if I can guess nole's target tonight correctly. And no, my claim can be proven without my plan. But if the herbalist is lynched, the town loses, end of discussion. The werewolf will kill someone tonight, and that will be the end (check the rules w_m, werewolf wins when half the town is dead, and there are only the three definite roles, no others in play).
|
|
|
Post by Nac Runo on Nov 6, 2009 18:58:02 GMT -5
p.s. is this day ending in about 23 hours or 35? Since i postponed the day 1 deadline by 12 hours it will propogate to today also. So around 35 hours till the day ends.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on Nov 6, 2009 20:33:25 GMT -5
w-m, here's the thing....as much as you think goltar would not want you around, he had to go after a proven townie, thus my protection on fbz last night. The one hole in his claim is this - He should have came out first thing since there would be no other reason to keep the herbalist hidden any longer.
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Nov 7, 2009 2:28:11 GMT -5
he had to go after a proven townie, There's only one varmint, EVERYone else is a honest soul. Which brings me to the next point, why in the name of all that's holy did ya go for some one who's one time use skill was used up?!?! There was a 50/50 chance to hit the herbalist and it's not like fbz had any special insight to give (other than he drunkenly stummbled on to your trail yesterday, in vino veritas.) The sherriff's ain't showed up in ages. Nah, goltar ah'd hit me in the hopes I was a doc type or at least claim whatever I was claimin' come morning 'cause there ain't no way for me ta prove one way or 'tother. The one hole in his claim is this - He should have came out first thing since there would be no other reason to keep the herbalist hidden any longer. Other than to catch some one tryin' to strech the truth so far it gets wrapped around itself.....
|
|
friedbananazzzz
New Member
My eyes are blue, and I don't lie about there being silver in them.
Posts: 47
|
Post by friedbananazzzz on Nov 7, 2009 12:04:15 GMT -5
Sorry, came down with a really bad flu, was stuck in bed for most of yesterday. The walls of text hurt my head (especially the RP one), but from what I can glean I think I'm gonna play along with the majority of the group.
unvote: goltar vote: nolecub
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Nov 7, 2009 20:10:36 GMT -5
Right sorry to hear yer feelin' puny fbz. Sure it ain't still a hang over? O/c when you're under the weather is when you can call brandy medicinal and have a tot.
|
|
|
Post by Nac Runo on Nov 8, 2009 8:39:50 GMT -5
Day 2 is over, Nolecub is lycnhed.
Nolecub was the sole anti-town role. Unfortunately for him, his gamble didn't work. The town wins.
The roles: water_moon: plain towny goltar: herbalist nolecub: werewolf friedbananazzzz: mystery role
The exact description of the mystery role as i sent to fried: "Your role enables you to stop a lynch. But there is a condition.
Your and the werewolf player's vote should be placed on different players. If the werewolf votes a no lycnh, then you can stop the lycnh as long as you place a vote. If the werewolf player votes for a lynch than you may not vote for a no lynch if you want to use your ability to stop the lycnh. "
Night actions: goltar protected fried, and nolecub chose not to target anyone.
I was actually thinking that the game was going to be to the advantage of the werewolf, therefore i introduced the no-lycnh voting and a role that forces that. The limitation i gave to fried was so that he wouldn't be sure of his role success and thus role claim. But as far as i observed he started the game by making others vote for him and by-pass the limitation i introduced, it worked. I was expecting the town to argue for a no-lynch but that never happened.
Sorry nole for making it as if you were destined to get lynched =).
Hope you all enjoyed it at least. But we certainly need more people to keep this going.
Nac.
|
|
|
Post by goltar on Nov 8, 2009 9:51:11 GMT -5
Thanks for hosting Nac, it was fun.
nole, why didn't you target anybody?
|
|