|
Post by Nac Runo on Sept 10, 2009 8:38:09 GMT -5
Congratulations to Ray for winning with a post Also congratulations to the mafia team, they did a very good job at creating confusion and coming victor over the town. So was there a target for first night NK or not? Who was the target? Also thanks to nole for hosting. It was an interesting round for sure. @liq: I was so sure that you were going to get lynched as a mafia that i didn't even thought of questioning you the day earlier. Also i gave absolutely zero credit to your town immortal claim :banghead:, but it turned out to be a nice tactical comment on your part. Did you really catch my 'hint' as the investigation role as i assumed or was it just my imagination? I hope you stay around for next rounds and drag others with you (eg. Ray ). You are really missed in these games, :thumbsup: FIREHORSE: I think you should have role revealed the previous day since you knew that soy was mafia. It wasn't going to matter if you get NK'ed at that point anyway and every bit of info always helps the town. Of course i should also have caught your hint at knowing the truth behind my words. Now, who is next in hosting . I can fill in if nobody wants to but i prefer we at least decide on next one to host.
|
|
|
Post by skoolbus on Sept 10, 2009 12:26:50 GMT -5
Good job scum.
VI is a dumb role, rewarding people for getting lynched has no place in mafia.
I followed along after I died, I think that Soy claimed that she bussed Ray and Fire night zero, which would have meant I blocked Fire, but she still voted for Ray. Figured she was scum when that happened.
Nac, no idea what you were doing day one, but when you switched votes like you did, it seemed really fishy.
Oh well, it was fun. Thanks.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Sept 10, 2009 13:31:48 GMT -5
Bah... And yet another time I wind up barking at the wrong tree. But still, Nac, had your day 1 behavior been more consistent, I would have backed off. As it was, you looked quite wishywashy to me. Liquid played different then he used to, but I figured that was due to a smaller amount of players and coming back from vacation. Soy was too exuberant in her opening post perhaps. But I knew for certain she was mafia when she took my role, dammit! As far as the whole Ray situation goes, the reasonig is simple: Night 1 there is no kill. Skool, in his dying post, claims that Ray is bad. The logical conclusion being that he blocked Ray night 1. So naturally, the town votes for Ray. And all he has to do, is make a post saying that he won't mind dying to give info to the town. He was quite lucky, he could win BECAUSE he had said next to nothing. If you put a role like a village idiot in a small group, it seems prudent to me to give warning that there is a faction that wins when lynched. This way, there was no way we could anticipate it. Night 1, I did nothing. Night 2, I switched Soy and Liq (IIRC) (yeah, fat lot of good THAT did us... Me, chauffeur of the mafia Xpress) Night 3, I was slaughtered just a little bit. Day 4, I got an apoplexy when Soy claimed my role. Night 4, I gnawed on my hat in frustration. Thank you for that Merlin. Liquid and I purposefully kept him quiet in case there was a snoop. This explains why Liquid was seen as active on night 2 even tho I put in the hit. I took your role claim because when Liquid was seen as night active I was trying to make him look like a night target=town. All of the other switches I claimed were meaningless. Skool you saying you blocked Ray so when I say I switched him with Fire and we had no NK - how does that prove I am scum? Either way we had no NK - that logic only works once you know that Ray was our first target for NK. Fire said he protected Ray so the blocking or switching was irrelevant.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Sept 10, 2009 13:33:22 GMT -5
and oh yes - you made me laugh with that post Merlin.
|
|
Liquid Evil
Full Member
The silver in my eyes cuts through any lies.
Posts: 219
|
Post by Liquid Evil on Sept 10, 2009 16:26:30 GMT -5
@liq: I was so sure that you were going to get lynched as a mafia that i didn't even thought of questioning you the day earlier. Also i gave absolutely zero credit to your town immortal claim :banghead:, but it turned out to be a nice tactical comment on your part. Did you really catch my 'hint' as the investigation role as i assumed or was it just my imagination? I hope you stay around for next rounds and drag others with you (eg. Ray ). You are really missed in these games, :thumbsup: I didn't catch your hints, but you know that I like to appear as if I catch everything. As to your other question, Ray was the 1st night target. Soy picked most of the NK targets; I think I only really voiced for Sitro's demise and that I didn't want Nac NK'ed on the final night (so that I could get the copster lynched for that sweet, sweet 2nd place finish). Admittedly, I played softball and didn't post my usual ungodly amount, and the questions I threw out were weaker than normal (because I wasn't really trying to gain anything more than looking like I was participating). Most people seemed to acknowledge that and gave me the benefit of the doubt for the first couple days. I'll probably stay around and add my name to the host list, but we really need to do something about the level of activity here. Mafia is much more fun with 15+ person games. Another thing we should consider is no NK the first night (just kill the host of the game if you want to roleplay). Also, maybe a PM campaign to the old regulars to make them aware of the games might be in order. I volunteer Nole to do that. ;D
|
|
|
Post by raypatean on Sept 10, 2009 21:21:22 GMT -5
Best Village Idiot EVER! You guys made it too easy for me.
|
|
|
Post by FIREHORSE on Sept 11, 2009 4:31:39 GMT -5
I agree with the no NK on Night #1. Mafia should always begin with a DAY IMO because either a mafia or Town has a chance being killed.
Beginning on a Night kills off one Town and there is nothing the Town can do about it. Begin with conversation (Day) not a NK.
My 2 cents.
I would also like to see different tie breaker rules rather than "The first to get their licks in and vote"
I say this cause I am not in North America and it seems that anyone who is not is a wee bit disadvantaged OR you could argue that the time zone of the host hinders or helps other players.
My suggestion? 2nd last vote breaks the tie or 3rd last or something akin to that.
Some players fail to vote and as votes get tossed around it may prove an interesting strategy.
That was a good round even though we had few numbers.
And I agree - I dislike that VI role too.
I have an idea to host a game....(With a few new ideas) however since I've never done so yet I may wish to play another round or two before attempting to host a game.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on Sept 11, 2009 10:41:06 GMT -5
Don't be so quick to get rid of the night 1 NK. .
Knowing the mafia cannot kill on night one generates ZERO discussion day 1.
At least with a night 1 NK, the town power roles also get to use their abilities to start forming a game plan.
|
|
friedbananazzzz
New Member
My eyes are blue, and I don't lie about there being silver in them.
Posts: 47
|
Post by friedbananazzzz on Sept 11, 2009 17:08:07 GMT -5
Thanks nole for hosting. Just please don't anyone include the VI role ever again. I agree with nole, there needs to be some action night one, otherwise there's nothing to talk about on day one.
|
|
|
Post by FIREHORSE on Sept 12, 2009 9:02:39 GMT -5
Thanks nole for hosting. Just please don't anyone include the VI role ever again. I agree with nole, there needs to be some action night one, otherwise there's nothing to talk about on day one. What about the weather? We can talk about that? "Nice day isnt it" Sounds pretty suspicious to me
|
|
friedbananazzzz
New Member
My eyes are blue, and I don't lie about there being silver in them.
Posts: 47
|
Post by friedbananazzzz on Sept 12, 2009 13:10:32 GMT -5
lol 10 chars
|
|
SiTro
Junior Member
Posts: 56
|
Post by SiTro on Sept 12, 2009 13:12:49 GMT -5
Casting suspicion on yourself? Sounds like a fishy bluff there...
Vote: FIREHORSE
Hey, cheers for hosting nole, had a lot of fun. Continued watching the game after I died (*Shakes fist* grr), and was a good read throughout.
For the record I chose to use my ability on Liq the first night. Seemed like a reliable person to keep discussion going in the thread. Second night I chose Nac Runo.
1 mafia, 1 town choice. Pretty even.
Hope you all had fun!
|
|