Sorry for the long post but bear with me.
First of all about Liq's challenge. I am 100% sure that he is not what he claims to be. Because i said that i saw him active last night and his claim doesn't seem to have any night activity. And since our "bus driver" didn't mention any switching of Liq last night the person i saw active MUST be Liq. There is no such case that both Liq and i am townie. If we go ahead and lynch Liq, and he turns out to be what he claims he is, then by all means you can lynch me tomorrow.
FIREHORSE: There is no possibility that everyone is telling the truth. You should just decide who is bluffing and who is not.
@soy:
1. How did you make such a conclusion from that post? Everything i said since the beginning of the day has been the truth. I am saying that the town can win over the mafia only if other townies believe me and i am working my *ss to come up with as solid evidence as i can to prove my role.
2. I am saying that there should be only 2 mafia left. What is confusing with that? Do you think it would have been better if we think there is 1 mafia left and it turns out to be 2 instead? I believe that the town should think of the worst possible scenario to survive. If we assume there is 2 mafia left and it turns out to be only one mafia then there is no harm for the town. I think you are the only one confusing there.
3. First of all, i said the title of my role is the Town Drunk. And in my previous post i said that my role allows me to check if someone was active every night. These are everything there is to my role, nothing else. The meaning to my role is that i watch the streets every night and i can remember if i saw a specific person at night. But since i am so drunk i can't recall if that person was working for the mafia or for the town.
The town drunk you mention to have is totally different than the role i possess. That sobering up town drunk role was something i have not experienced before. In short, your knowledge of town drunk from the previous role has nothing to do with my claim.
4. Read above.
5. Read above, i never said i have the role you previously had and i don't understand how you call me out on something i didn't claim to have.
6. The blocker doesn't have anything to do with my role results since i either get blocked and can't make an investigation (this is what happened on night 2 even though skool was lynched beforehand, which makes me almost certaion that there is another blocker in this game), or my target is inactive due to being blocked but since both the targets i saw were active this is not something we need to discuss currently. The switcher can of course make my readings invalid but since none of the targets you listed matches with my targets it shouldn't be the case so far.
I'm sorry I have been trying to follow you but this does not make sense how can the doctor confirm your role?
7. Here is what i thought; i inspected you the first night and you turned out to be active. But i was assuming that nole forbid NK on the first night so no mafia member was going to be active in my reasoning. Making me to think that you were an active townie i saw. How this is going to veryify me you ask. I inserted a hint to my role claim saying that you were the one i saw active on night one. I will quote myself again on this:
I only meant what i said about doc protecting
herself.
Before you even claimed to have a role i said that the doc is a SHE. I was hoping that such a hint was enough to earn the towns trust. After all you are the only SHE in this game and i can know of your role only if i am telling the truth. I was wrong in my assumption as you being the doc your claim tells that i was right about you being active on night 1. This should be the proof of my role as seeing night activity but not exact role.
This should be all the questions i guess, if anyone has anything else i would be glad to answer.
Now, i have a few questions of my own.
@soy:
1. Do you role has any power to change NK target. Meaning do you claim to have saved yourself last night by switching merlin and yourself since merlin got NK'ed?
2. What do you think of your first night targets? You switched Ray with Firehorse and we lynched ray because he was blocked the first night. If you claim is true that skool must have blocked Firehorse instead. Yet you never questioned anything about Firehorse even though you were the only one knowing the truth about skool's claim.
Two things i know is that (1) Liquid is not telling the truth with his role, therefore he should be mafia. (2) Soy was active the first night but that doesn't make her mafia or bus driver.