|
Post by goltar on May 13, 2009 22:48:00 GMT -5
water_moon has been killed.
Alive:
firehorse nolecub soylentred
Dead:
raypatean water_moon
Day 2 has begun. PM your bids to me for the investigation of the day.
|
|
|
Post by FIREHORSE on May 14, 2009 3:44:36 GMT -5
Well this is interesting. I agree with the vote on Ray because he was a non poster but I went mid stream and voted for Noleclub. It was because Ray did not post that I did not figure he'd be Mafia. I also did not vote for Water Moon because she was the most vocal. I am not surprised that Water was killed.
Noleclub & Soylent - each of you hung in the middle and I figured was the safest bet for a vote.
The question now is - which one of you two is more suspicious. Water Moon and Soylent were at odds yesterday. Noleclub and Water Moon not as much. That switcheroo by Noleclub yesterday caused me not to switch my vote off you and place it on Ray.
Noleclub: Are you surprised Water Moon was killed?
Soylent: Do you think Nole's switcheroo yesterday was an excellent ploy?
Votes for himself then votes off Ray. Raised Eyebrow on that.
I still think between the two of you that Nole you are more likely to be Mafia than Soylent. I am not getting Mafia vibes from her.
So lets try this again
VOTE NOLECLUB:
PS: Noleclub I am willing to switch my vote depending upon what is said today. But for now, this is where my instincts tell me to put it.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on May 14, 2009 8:15:48 GMT -5
I am not suprised water_moon was NK'd...I am pissed that she was NK'd.
I won the daily investigation bid yesterday,spending all of my loot....$51. Investigated water_moon, and she turned out to be the town aligned thief.
As for today, I truly have no idea. Looks like we will have to have a repeat of last game and let soy decide.
vote:firehorse
Reason: Really a no win situation for me here. No matter which way I vote, it can be spun pretty easily. Going with FH here because soy is cuter. With water_moon gone, I have no alibi and can really prove nothing. I have no role of my own, just a plain townie. I am hoping I was given more cash to compensate for that fact.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on May 14, 2009 17:57:09 GMT -5
Noleclub: Are you surprised Water Moon was killed? Soylent: Do you think Nole's switcheroo yesterday was an excellent ploy? Votes for himself then votes off Ray. Raised Eyebrow on that. I still think between the two of you that Nole you are more likely to be Mafia than Soylent. I am not getting Mafia vibes from her. So lets try this again VOTE NOLECLUB: PS: Noleclub I am willing to switch my vote depending upon what is said today. But for now, this is where my instincts tell me to put it. To answer your question a ploy yes, excellent remains to be seen. I said that yesterday - I did not believe Nole's claim based on him stating he was plain useless townie and I know I have that role and in a game of 5 it is unlikely to have 2 plain inoffensive types. I voted Ray all the while voicing my suspicion of Nole. Come on Fire let's put this baby to bed... vote:Nolecub
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on May 14, 2009 18:14:05 GMT -5
I placed an investigation bid but was not the winner.
Another point going against Nole here is we were given different amounts of money. I have less than what he claims to have. The story of him being a second vanilla townie again is not washing.
|
|
|
Post by goltar on May 14, 2009 23:53:20 GMT -5
Mid-day update. The high bid is currently $47, and the votes are:
nolecub - 2 firehorse - 1
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on May 15, 2009 8:24:00 GMT -5
Soy, why would you have 3 power town roles in a game of 5?? I believe it makes more sense to only have 1 or 2 townie roles against 1 mafia.
If you are in fact a townie, rethink how you would structure this game. Would you really put 3 power roles in??
To be honest, I really don't know which of you two is the mafia at this point, so to whomever it is: good game.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on May 15, 2009 8:27:33 GMT -5
Unvote: firehorse Vote:soy
FH: Do you believe that soy is telling the truth?
"I voted Ray all the while voicing my suspicion on Nole"...a little defensive there especially since no one has questioned your vote on Ray.
|
|
|
Post by FIREHORSE on May 15, 2009 19:09:36 GMT -5
So far Soylent has done nothing to make me believe she is not telling the truth.
I think she is Town.
Although I've been fooled before. I guess by changing your vote you have now thrown the ball in my court to do something about it.
Status quo or change my vote.
And Noleclub if you are Mafia like I suspect - you've got the game. Its a crap shoot. I guess what I had said about their being only 1 mafia ""seems""" to be correct. You investigated Water and she showed Town - according to you.
Which leaves Ray.
In a small game I think you decided to go guts or glory and throw suspicion off yourself Nole, by voting for yourself.
Convince me otherwise......
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on May 15, 2009 20:19:40 GMT -5
Soy, why would you have 3 power town roles in a game of 5?? I believe it makes more sense to only have 1 or 2 townie roles against 1 mafia. If you are in fact a townie, rethink how you would structure this game. Would you really put 3 power roles in?? To be honest, I really don't know which of you two is the mafia at this point, so to whomever it is: good game. Why? Maybe because Goltar went to the trouble to outline 10 or 11 roles for the game. So by consensus we have 1 mafia and by your suggestion maybe a doctor, maybe a cop but not one more town role. You say Water was a thief and then we have none of the other suggested roles for this game. We have no way of confirming your investigation - a sure thing for mafia and common as dirt to claim or pronounce a role once someone is dead and can't call you out on it. Does anyone think our non posting Ray could be the mafia - not be able to post one word in the game but managing to get the NK in?
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on May 15, 2009 20:20:50 GMT -5
Sorry - I forgot Ray was dead already - he continued his quiet trend so well.
|
|
|
Post by goltar on May 15, 2009 22:48:47 GMT -5
Alright, there's no point dragging this out further. The final vote count for the day:
nolecub - 2 soylent - 1
Looks like nolecub is lynched.
Congratulations are in order. Good game firehorse, as the lone mafia, you outlasted the town. Here's the role breakdown:
firehorse - plain mafia nolecub - plain townie raypatean - town doctor soylentred - plain townie water_moon - town thief
I started everyone with a random amount of money, all very close ($48 - $55 range).
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on May 16, 2009 9:22:22 GMT -5
Arggh - ok that is it Fire I am never trusting you again Congratulations on your win. Nole - I really did see your early actions as a ploy and not the selfless act they turned out to be.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on May 16, 2009 11:02:59 GMT -5
First thanks for goltar for hosting, it was fun. Nice and quick game with a twist. Would love to play this theme again.
Second - gratz on a well played game firehorse. It appeared to me that you had a little change in play style that threw you on my radar. Excellent job on taking control of the second day and casting out the first vote.
Soy - I truly was going to sacrifice myself the first day when I saw I was a plain townie. With so little conversation, I did not want a power role to be lost. Of course, ray was mia as it was, so he could not defend himself.
With more participants, this will be a truly fun theme to play again.
|
|
|
Post by FIREHORSE on May 16, 2009 19:34:58 GMT -5
Thanks Goltar for hosting the game. Too bad we did not have more players. Ironically Noleclub you casting suspicion upon yourself saved you. Ray was lynched by all of you for being quiet. I never voted for him. Given the different rules this game I wasn't sure whether I had an NK on Night #1 or not. Turns out I did but found out too late to use it. And in my opinion i should not have gotten one anyway as it would have made a game of this size too easy for the mafia. So y'all gotta free pass on night one. Since Nole cast a lot of doubt upon himself I did not want to NK him. I kept him alive and axed Water Moon instead. I knew Soy was suspicious of Nole and sought to use that as my advantage. I owe Soylentred a huge apology. I am very sorry. I was forced into this life of crime. I never chose it. Hopefully next game we get more players as Goltar's idea was a good one.
|
|