|
Post by merlin on Dec 5, 2009 14:59:44 GMT -5
Nac, I assumed we wouldn't get a mafia on the first day vote. I decided to vote for you to make sure not all the votes piled up on the same person. That turned out fine. final tally: nole (2) you, pendraggin. me (1) nole and you (1) me.
water_moon didn't vote. That is a rather essential fault, which actually makes me believe she is townie. Why? Because I think that if she was mafia, she would have enough sense of fair play to place a vote and give the civvies a fighting chance.
After nole was lynched, you picked pendraggin as a NK target, because you wanted to make w_m look bad for missing the vote, and avoid the revenge kill suspicion for me voting for you. I feel rather good about you being the 1 remaining mafia.
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Dec 6, 2009 3:35:57 GMT -5
@w_m: What do you think the NKs reveal. Also how did you connect NK of N1 and N2. You said pendraggin's dead would only mean deny'ing information but i don't see what you mean there too. From the first day posts i was inclined to think w_m as more townie conpared to others but lack of voting is always bad for town. I don't understand why everybody played it safe and kept their votes anyway. What did anyone wait for? A confess from the mafia? (OK, I lost my entire post while proof reading so if I'm skipping a few steps somewhere it's because I though I already said it, and I did, it was just lost...) I didn't vote simply because I expected to come back before the end of day. And I'm not about to vote first post of the day and let some mafia swan in behind me on a safe bandwagon. The denying of info reasoning would be following the line that because pen is new to us, where targeting any of the rest of us would set up for reading into the death of a known figure. The NK links are that they're both suble set ups of me, assuming I were thinking like Nac. (Goltar, so obivious even pen noted it and disregaurded it, but that meantion and discounting could be read as defending me, and Nac likes to kill his defenders to throw suspcion off of himself.) Now, merlin could have been feeling safe to vote differntly because he figured a townie was likly to die, but my vote held in abeyance to the last minute meant a tie invloving him was more than possible and thus I think he would have voted for the lead rather than spreading the vote. Also throwing out the first vote of the day on to a townie IS dangerous, esp. when the the bandwagoner is then NK'ed. But the maifa has to risk it this round and Nac left a cop alive for THREE DAYS after he'd revealed in another round. If that ain't guts I don't know what is. tl, dr: The kills fit Nac and merlin wouldn't have tried to set up his own lynch Vote: Nac Runo
|
|
|
Post by Jason Maher on Dec 6, 2009 18:10:41 GMT -5
Day is over, Nac Runo is dead. He was the lone Mafia.
Thus the game is over. Congratulations townies!
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on Dec 6, 2009 18:26:58 GMT -5
gg Townies.
|
|
|
Post by Nac Runo on Dec 6, 2009 19:17:34 GMT -5
GG everyone. I didn't think i would be that easy to read with the NK choices. I didn't plan on going after w_m with goltar lynch though. As w_m said, goltar is usually the one less likely to follow someone elses logic so i chose him as the first NK. I wanted to keep w_m around and wanted to go after merlin as the lynch target but never had the chance to convey my logic.
Thanks for hosting Jason.
|
|
|
Post by merlin on Dec 7, 2009 19:13:34 GMT -5
GG. Nice try Nac. The two scenario's (different setups of plain townies vs 1 mafia or 2 mafia vs Cop, Doc and townies) needed different times to start. the first in a nighttime, the second in a daytime. The second especially in a daytime. As for the rest, I just looked where the votes stood, and based my vote for you on nothing else then indeed spreading out the votes, We wouldn't learn a thing from everybody piling up on one person, so that seemed like the best bet. I hadn't even thought about how that would paint me townie, but w_m had it right of course
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Dec 8, 2009 20:58:58 GMT -5
GG all, thaks for hosting Jason! Sorry Nac, maybe you shouldn't have explained your reasoning so often as a mafia..... I'm just glad I didn't have to defend myself, and that I avenged goltar's death. In the end it's pure and simple logic in a nice and simple game.
|
|
|
Post by goltar on Dec 10, 2009 14:35:40 GMT -5
That was fun to watch. I can't recall being the night 1 kill before.
|
|