|
Post by soylentred on Apr 24, 2009 21:21:22 GMT -5
wow I don't have quite so much logic behind this as the idea that water has been leading or trying to lead us around by the nose - I have been suspicious of her. going to read a couple of things and vote soon.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Apr 24, 2009 21:27:20 GMT -5
here goes
vote: Water_moon
and I am sorry if I am wrong.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on Apr 25, 2009 11:48:41 GMT -5
You made the correct choice soy.
Noone even questioned w_m on her choices for investigation last night. Why did she choose myself and soy to be investigated? She knew that the only way to cast doubt on today's proceedings is to not have anyone investigated that had been (or was going to be) NK'd.
Scenario 1: I investigate soy who would show mafia to me (being insane). Now that would leave the chance that I could be the normal cop and vote to lynch soy since w_m showed cop on night 1. w_m further expoits this possibility in her first post today where she hints at being paranoid and throws soy's name out as mafia.
Scenario 2: I investigate muzzz or even firehorse. Since they are both proven cops, they would (and did in the case of muzzz) to show as mafia. Since my night one investigation of w_m showed her as a cop, that now meant she was the lone mafia.
Granted, I do not believe that w_m knew who had which cop role, but she had to know that I was either insane or naive. Muzzz had to be insane or paranoid since he claimed that I showed mafia on night one. That leaves firehorse and soy as the only options left to being the normal cop. Since soy did no investigation on night one, w_m was unable to know for sure if soy was normal or naive.
|
|
|
Post by Nac Runo on Apr 25, 2009 18:07:11 GMT -5
The day is over, w_m is accused of being the treacherous cop and jailed for that. Here is the actual role distribution.
firehorse: sane cop muzzz: paranoid cop soylentred: naive cop nolecub: insane cop
water_moon: wicked cop
Good job townies cops, you did a good job on cathing the killer.
Nac.
|
|
|
Post by nolecub on Apr 25, 2009 18:22:57 GMT -5
***steals soy's Snoopy dance*** Great job everyone. Nice strategy at the end w_m. I was afk for the latter part of the day, all of the night, and first part of the new day, so I couldn't question your choices for targets. In hindsight, it was better I didn't, less ammunition for you Thank you for hosting Nac. That was a nice change of pace using **gasp** actual logic instead of brow beating information from someone. I do miss the beatings though....
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Apr 25, 2009 18:31:09 GMT -5
I actully didn't know who I wanted to kill until the last moment, muzz was my target because he's more logcal. And the investigation targets was using logic to get the maximum information, presuming everyone lived. Sadly I couldn't defend myself by pointing out the logic b/c the time I didn't spend with a sick baby I was busy eatting lunch. You see, I woulcd never target firehorse for a night 1 night kill. In fact I didn't, but due to a lack of play I was asked to switch targets.
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Apr 25, 2009 18:41:38 GMT -5
And soy, in response to your reply the last day, if I WERE a good cop and investigating nole and was NOT paranoid, but insane, that would leave you as mafia. With the reveal I gave day one I was either paranoid or insane. If nole is mafia and I get mafia on him then I'm not insane therefore I'm paranoid. If I'm not paranoid (nole is not mafia), then you are. It's logical decuction. Not an accusation.
You're just lucky as sin that I wasn't a good cop.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Apr 25, 2009 21:26:40 GMT -5
And soy, in response to your reply the last day, if I WERE a good cop and investigating nole and was NOT paranoid, but insane, that would leave you as mafia. With the reveal I gave day one I was either paranoid or insane. If nole is mafia and I get mafia on him then I'm not insane therefore I'm paranoid. If I'm not paranoid (nole is not mafia), then you are. It's logical decuction. Not an accusation. You're just lucky as sin that I wasn't a good cop. Argh - too much the vestle with the pestle has the brew that is true - I am still confused. The trouble with that explanation W_M is it arrives at me being wicked and I knew I wasn't. Good game all - thanks.
|
|
|
Post by Nac Runo on Apr 26, 2009 3:33:39 GMT -5
You see, I woulcd never target firehorse for a night 1 night kill. In fact I didn't, but due to a lack of play I was asked to switch targets. Yes, this is something i should underline. At the time w_m actually wanted to kill Muzzz for a first night kill but i asked her if she could switch her target to either firehorse or soy. I didn't hear from either of them till that time and didn't want the game to proceed with only 2 active players. Sorry for interrupting your plans once again w_m, and thanks for understanding. I wish you luck for the next time =).
|
|
|
Post by muzzz on Apr 26, 2009 6:46:47 GMT -5
Should I switch 'most usual suspect' to 'most usual target'? The last day was fun to watch. I had a little more info than the rest of the town, 'cause I was dead. So I already knew that only W_M could be guilty. We should do this again, sometime.
|
|
|
Post by soylentred on Apr 26, 2009 16:39:48 GMT -5
I apologize for being late into the game - I was totally watching my inbox to know when the game started instead of watching the thread. Also I wondered if anyone would have figured out I was cop on that basis.
|
|
|
Post by water_moon on Apr 27, 2009 13:44:03 GMT -5
And soy, in response to your reply the last day, if I WERE a good cop and investigating nole and was NOT paranoid, but insane, that would leave you as mafia. With the reveal I gave day one I was either paranoid or insane. If nole is mafia and I get mafia on him then I'm not insane therefore I'm paranoid. If I'm not paranoid (nole is not mafia), then you are. It's logical decuction. Not an accusation. You're just lucky as sin that I wasn't a good cop. Argh - too much the vestle with the pestle has the brew that is true - I am still confused. The trouble with that explanation W_M is it arrives at me being wicked and I knew I wasn't. Good game all - thanks. Or nole being guilty (me paranoid and you naive) BTW, muzz did you investigate soy? (you would have gotten guilty, so my other option to target was her and to try to pin the blame on nole.)
|
|
|
Post by muzzz on Apr 27, 2009 14:52:10 GMT -5
Yeah, I did. That other plan might actually have worked pretty well, assuming you claimed differently.
|
|